It could be that in soccer clutch skill does indeed exist. Also, I shouldn't be so dismissive of the skill in baseball. To expand even further, they have shown that the player that is most likely to be "clutch" by the average definition of clutch is someone who puts the ball in play a lot. That, though, doesn't really tie into clutch since how frequently a player hits the ball into play isn't related to the score, but rather that player's own skill set. Anyway, I wouldn't be surprised at all if it exists in soccer or might be a situation (I don't watch soccer so apologies if I butcher the terms) where one team is putting its best defender on a player (Henry) and not the other (Gerrard). That's one of the beautiful things about baseball. It's a series of events that are largely independent of what the team as a whole does. Batter vs. pitcher, ball in play vs. fielder, fielder vs. base runner and so on. That's what makes baseball so easy to quantify and it's why statisticians love it. There is so much data to dig into. There's very little that happens in baseball that's not individually achieved whereas in a sport like soccer I imagine you have players trying to create spacing for others (scorers) so all of that works together.