I had completely forgotten about that setting! Gah.
I set it to see how that works out. It's pretty close to be honest. Not exactly what I'm looking for since I'd like to be able to leave the one finder window open on desktop 1 in it's current spot, though I feel like I'm being picky now...
If anyone is feeling adventurous then perhaps they want to give this a shot? If not, I'll compromise.
Thanks for the tip though Tyler!