Jump to content
rdg

Eject/Eject All lacks notifications for physical volumes

Recommended Posts

For some reason, physical disks & thumb drives connected to my computer do not get notifications posted to the OS when I eject them through the system commands in Alfred. Oddly, DMG volumes that are ejected via Alfred commands _do_ cause notifications to pop up, letting me know the eject has been successful.

 

Alfred version: 2.6

OS Version: 10.10.2

Edited by rdg

Share this post


Link to post

For some reason, physical disks & thumb drives connected to my computer do not get notifications posted to the OS when I eject them through the system commands in Alfred. Oddly, DMG volumes that are ejected via Alfred commands _do_ cause notifications to pop up, letting me know the eject has been successful.

 

Alfred version: 2.6

OS Version: 10.10.2

 

Apologies for the slow reply.

 

I've tested this with the latest Alfred and OS X versions and can't replicate the behaviour you're seeing. If I eject a connected USB key or external drive, the notification for it appears as expected.

 

Is it possible that you're trying to eject a second volume on the same physical drive as another one you've already ejected but is still shown by OS X? And are you still experiencing this issue?

Share this post


Link to post

No, it's not a second volume on the drive(s) I'm ejecting. One is an file-vault encrypted volume though (my portable Time Machine backup).

 

Edit: I just checked with a thumb drive formatted for Windows (ExFat), and when I ejected it, I got a notification. So it may be that my other drives that lack notifcations are all Mac OS X formatted + encrypted volumes.

Edited by rdg

Share this post


Link to post

No, it's not a second volume on the drive(s) I'm ejecting. One is an file-vault encrypted volume though (my portable Time Machine backup).

 

Edit: I just checked with a thumb drive formatted for Windows (ExFat), and when I ejected it, I got a notification. So it may be that my other drives that lack notifcations are all Mac OS X formatted + encrypted volumes.

 

So your conclusion to date is that this exclusively happens with encrypted volumes? If so, I'll have a play with this and see whether I can replicate it. In the meantime, please keep me updated on any more findings :)

Share this post


Link to post

I don't have a lot of physical media to experiment with, but it does seem to be a file vault 2 problem. I reformatted that vfat thumb drive as a Mac formatted file vault 2 drive, and the eject command failed to send a notification. It ejects fine, but I have to check the Finder to verify that it did eject.

Edited by rdg

Share this post


Link to post

I don't have a lot of physical media to experiment with, but it does seem to be a file vault 2 problem. I reformatted that vfat thumb drive as a Mac formatted file vault 2 drive, and the eject command failed to send a notification. It ejects fine, but I have to check the Finder to verify that it did eject.

 

Having investigated this further, it looks like a Mac-formatted, journaled USB key that's an encrypted volume doesn’t give an eject notification, while a normal non-encrypted one does. It looks like OS X takes a little longer ejecting these encrypted volumes, by which time Alfred is attempting to eject a second time.

 

I've added a ticket for Andrew to look into this further in an upcoming update. :)

Share this post


Link to post

I must have been busy when you posted, and then I forgot about the thread. Just to clarify, what you've surmised is true, but it's also true of an external Mac-formatted, encrypted & journaled hard drive hooked up via usb3… not just a USB key drive.

Share this post


Link to post
×
×
  • Create New...