Hey, thanks. I thought I did that (I looked at the help page before posting here), but I'll mess around with with settings again and see if the settings are off.
EDIT #1
I just reviewed the instructions again. The instructions reference tell you to right click on the sync folder to ensure it's set on "local" storage (rather than online only). There's no option that describes 'local storage' other than 'make available offline.' I tried that without any success, but I will try again.
EDIT #2
Looked into this a bit more. Looks like SmartSync is only available for DropBox business, which I don't even have.